Nick's Fishmarket (Reported Closed)

Doesn't Recommend

carthrey

Joined 6 years ago

They used to be so good.... I took friends and family to Nick's on Christmas day. It was a disaster!

o The service was *very* slow (even though we selected the special menu of the day)

o Some of the food was cold (cold steak is not very enjoyable)

o The staff had too many tables to service for the employee load

I suspect all the new development on Lewers Street is going to be the death of Nick's, especially if they don't get their act together.

They used to be "the" place to go in Waikiki. How times change...

Recommends

tedmatt

Joined 8 years ago

Great Evening. We took dear friends to Nick's to celebrate their 40th anniversary. The evening was simply delightful. I was like dinning in New York with leather chairs and booths, red carpet and excellent service. Our meals were served "just right" and we had some specific requests. I had the sea bass special which was prepared with a tomato base salsa that perfectly complimented the generous portion of fish. The lamb and steaks were excellent as well. When the bill came, I found that the prices were not high for Honolulu, but one has to keep in mind that Honolulu restaurants are a bit higher than Southern California where we come from. I highly recommend Nick's for dinner.

Doesn't Recommend

cdelgiorgio

Joined 8 years ago

Questionable Quality in Quantity!. Nick's is living on a past reputation that it no longer lives up to. The attitude that one encounters here are obviously from the glory years the once celebrated restaurant enjoyed. Although written up in several local restaurant reviews as one of the bestin Honolulu, of my 7 dinners out in February, it was by far the worst.

Three of our four meals were overcooked. My Ono was fishy and stunk.

We were ignored for most of the meal and were unable to protest the quality of our entrees until we asked for a check.

Definitely the most expensive dinner I had in Honolulu and by far the most disappointingprice doesnt mean quality here.